|
Compensation Design Group Has Perfect Solution
For Top Performing Baseball Players
NEW YORK, NY - March 26, 2002 -- With opening day
just around the corner, baseball fans will have an opportunity to
see which players worked out the kinks during spring training and
which ones deserve the outrageous salaries they're commanding, according
to Frank Glassner, CEO of Compensation Design Group.
"Some players are paid like the CEOs who run
companies in trouble," said Glassner, a 26-year veteran of
executive compensation. "They are paid for lackluster performance.
An ideal salary plan for players would be one based on the same
principles and procedures used for successful businesses - a plan
based heavily on incentives for performance."
"The current salary structure in major league
baseball is bloated and obscene," said Glassner. "Exorbitant
sports salaries and compensation packages have become synonymous
with the player as 'pay for ego' vs. 'pay for performance.' Last
year, baseball's average salary hit the $2 million mark, up 12.8
percent from the previous year's average."
In Glassner's plan, players would receive a base
salary determined by multiples of previous batting averages or pitching
records. They would earn set amounts for each of a list of positive
accomplishments: $10,000 per home run, for example, $2,500 for a
stolen base, $25,000 for a pitching win. In addition, there would
be bonus payments for winning championships or for being among league
leaders in various statistics.
Like every successful business person, Glassner
believes that risks should accompany opportunities. With this in
mind, his plan would levy a $1,000 tax for every failed steal attempt,
a hefty $5,000 for bouncing into double play, $1,000 a strikeout
or error.
Taking this plan and applying it directly to New
York Yankees' shortstop Derek Jeter, for example, might look something
like this:
| Jeter's base salary (last year's avg.): |
.311 x 1 million x 2.5 |
= 777,500 |
| Bonus of $25,000 for each 100 at-bats: |
614 ABs |
= 153,500 |
| Bonus of $50,000 for each 100 hits: |
191 hits |
= 95,500 |
| Bonus of $10,000 for each home run: |
21 home runs |
= 210,000 |
| Bonus of $5,000 for each RBI: |
74 RBIs |
= 370,000 |
| Bonus of $2,500 for each run scored: |
110 runs |
= 275,000 |
Based on his performance last season, Jeter's salary
would be $1,881,500. Under Glassner's plan a player gets an additional
$50,000 for making the All-Star team, $150,000 for winning the League
MVP. Leading the league in any of the following categories would
get a player $50,000 per category: batting average, home runs, RBIs,
hits, doubles or triples. If a team won the World Series, each player
would receive an additional $100,000 bonus.
"Under this plan, if players performed at their
maximum, they could actually earn their current mega salaries,"
said Glassner. "The incentive to perform at their optimum would
be simple: better performance, more money."
Glassner said that the incentives in his plan are
the basics of any solid compensation plan in a corporation. "For
the sports world, I believe that one more incentive might be appropriate:
a bonus based on being a good role model for kids," said Glassner.
"Whether players like it or not, they are in the position of
being role models. Under an ideal compensation plan, players who
perform community service and work with children would be properly
rewarded."
Glassner also believes that fans should have a say
in a player's bonus program. "In a corporate structure, directors
would vote on bonuses as rewards for performance and efforts. Baseball
fans are, in effect, a baseball team's shareholders," said
Glassner. "In that sense, they should be given the opportunity
to vote on a player's season-end bonus. With input from fans, rookies
who are stellar performers would be properly rewarded and players
who demonstrated poor performance throughout the season would get
what they deserved."
The pay for performance concept is applied to corporate
executives across the country today. "Why not apply this same
concept to professional athletes?" said Glassner. "Especially
now, as salaries have skyrocketed at an alarmingly high rate."
Glassner poses a few questions to sports fans: "Why
should the owners and fans alike have the guts to challenge the
players and instill a pay for performance philosophy along with
the rest of America?" he asked. "Why not continue this
complete insanity in sports compensation: huge salaries coupled
with poor performance; lack of team work; brutal money raids on
baseball, football and basketball teams; wild-eyed agents flying
around the country in Lear jets with huge sacks of cash and mind-bending
contracts for any player willing to challenge their team's owners
and any group of owners willing to pay the ransom for this form
of extortion?"
Although Glassner strongly believes his plan would
work, the union might be a major obstacle to implementing such a
plan. "This organization has, in its lifetime, become a legalized
and unregulated monopoly with power that amounts to life or death
over the fate of baseball salaries.," said Glassner.
Unfortunately, Glassner notes, in the end the fans
are the ones who lose if the current system continues. "If
sports teams dared to adopt a pay for performance plan, it could
actually improve the game," said Glassner. "Players may
become more motivated to improve skills and undertake a training
regime reflective of their salary. Owners certainly wouldn't complain
about rewarding performance. And the real winners would be the fans.
They would get to see an improved game with all players trying their
hardest, no matter where their team is in the standings."
Compensation Design Group is headquartered in New
York, with offices in Chicago and San Francisco. The firm focuses
on delivering cost effective and customized compensation, benefits
and human resources programs.
COMPENSATION DESIGN GROUP BASEBALL SALARY PLAN
Base Salaries:
Veterans would be paid a base salary that is based
on their prior year's batting average using the following formula:
B.A. x 1 million x multiple = base salary
The multiples are as follows:
BA under .100 = 5 multiple
.100 - .150 = 1
.151 - .200 = 1.25
.201 - .250 = 1.5
.251 - .300 = 2.0
.301 - .350 = 2.5
.351 - .400 = 3.0
So, if a player hit .155 last year, his base would
be:
.155 x 1 million x 1.25 = $193,750
A .330 hitter would make:
.330 x 1 million x 2.5 = $825,000
Base salaries for pitchers would be as follows:
Multiple x 100,000 = base salary
The multiples are as follows:
ERA under 1.00 = 8 multiple
1.01 - 1.50 = 7
1.51 - 2.00 = 6
2.01 - 2.50 = 5
2.51 - 3.00 = 4
3.01 - 3.50 = 3
3.51 - 4.00 = 2
4.01 - 4.50 = 1
4.51 - and above = .5
So, if a pitcher's ERA was 3.70 last year, his base
would be:
2 x 100,000 = $200,000
A pitcher with a 1.25 ERA would make:
7 x 100,000 = $700,000
Rookies (both batters and pitchers) with no prior
major league numbers would be paid the minimum of $100,000.
Add for each offensive stat:
| $2,5000 |
- Single |
| $5,000 |
- Double |
| $7,500 |
- Triple |
| $10,000 |
- Home run |
| $5,000 |
- RBI |
| $1,500 |
- Sacrifice |
| $2,000 |
- Game played |
| $2,500 |
- Stolen base |
| $2,000 |
- Hit by pitch |
| $2,000 |
- Base on balls |
| $2,500 |
- Run scored |
Add for each pitching stat:
| $25,000 |
- Pitching win |
| $50,000 |
- For ERA under 3.50 (all ERA stats based on
at least 60 innings) |
| $100,000 |
- For ERA under 3.00 |
| $150,000 |
- For ERA under 2.50 |
| $200,000 |
- For ERA under 2.00 |
| $250,000 |
- For ERA under 1.50 |
| $300,000 |
- For ERA under 1.00 |
| $10,000 |
- Pitching save |
| $2,500 |
- Pitching strikeout |
| $5,000 |
- Pitching game started |
| $10,000 |
- Pitching complete game |
| $2,000 |
- Pitching appearance in relief |
| $5,000 |
- Each run scored |
| $25,000 |
- Each 50 innings pitched above 100 |
Add for each defensive stat:
| $5,000 |
- For participating in double play |
| $500 |
- For each fielding assist |
Bonuses:
| $100,000 |
- For each 100 at-bats |
| $25,000 |
- For each 100 hits |
| $50,000 |
- For each 20 pitching starts |
| $50,000 |
- For making the All-star team |
| $50,000 |
- For wining League MVP |
| $150,000 |
- For winning CY Young Award |
| $150,000 |
- For team winning LCS |
| $50,000 |
- For winning World Series |
| $50,000 |
- For leading the league in any
of the following categories: |
| |
Batting average |
| |
Home runs |
| |
RBIs |
| |
Hits |
| |
Doubles |
| |
Triples |
| |
Pitching wins |
| |
ERA |
| |
Strikeouts |
| |
Saves |
| |
(subtract $10,000 for each place
on list below #1) |
Subtract for each:
| $2,500 |
- Error |
| $1,000 |
- Strikeout |
| $1,000 |
- Caught stealing |
| $5,000 |
- Hitting into double play |
| $10,000 |
- Pitching loss |
| $2,500 |
- Pitching blown save |
| $1,000 |
- Pitching base on balls |
| $2,500 |
- Wild pitch |
|